RFID Radiant Barrier Foil vs. Reflective Paint: Which is Better?

For those of us with dark-colored roofs, we’re familiar with how scorching it can get up there during the summer. The intense solar heat penetrates indoors through the rooftop, effectively turning the attic into an oven. Consequently, the heated attic conducts unwanted warmth into the rest of the house, placing additional strain on cooling systems, ultimately leading to higher utility bills. This is one of the factors contributing to the surge in expenses during the hottest days of summer. So, how do you prevent this scenario? How can you ensure that your insulation is operating at maximum efficiency? The key lies in lightening the load on your A/C system by minimizing heat gain. This is precisely the purpose of radiant barriers. When it comes to insulating your home against radiant heat, two popular options stand out: Spray-On Radiant Barrier Paint and Radiant Barrier Foil.

Radiant barriers employ aluminum to mitigate solar gains. They achieve this by reflecting the sun’s rays away from the air-conditioned structure. This action significantly enhances energy efficiency and reduces the associated costs of cooling. Radiant barrier insulation is particularly beneficial in hot and sunny climates, where it complements traditional insulation.

Spray-On Radiant Barrier paint, also known as “Radiation Control Coatings” (RCC) or “Interior Radiation Control Coating Systems,” (IRCCS) consists of standard water-based paint infused with pure, powdered aluminum or metallic flakes. While the purpose of the powdered aluminum is to impart radiant heat reflective properties, they can only achieve a peak of 75% (.25 emissivity) reflection under optimal conditions. Unfortunately, the real-world conditions in which radiant barrier paint proves effective are seldom encountered.

Consequently, according to research published by RIMA, products containing radiant barrier paint don’t technically meet the criteria to be labeled as radiant barriers. Standard definition requires an emittance value of 0.1 or less, a criteria these paint products don’t meet. “Radiant Barrier paint” is misleading, as it can only reflect about 75% of radiant heat. Additional research revealed some coatings had an emissivity as high as .90, indicating that only 10% of radiant heat was reflected. These figures align more with conductive insulation rather than reflective.

Radiant barrier paint spray is not a good Do It Yourself (DIY) project. The fumes can be harmful, necessitating the use of a VOC respirator. Additionally, you’ll need a high-quality airless spray rig, the appropriate-sized spray tip, and the right pressure to ensure proper coverage and prevent clogging. Using a roller is not feasible due to the numerous nails protruding through the roof deck. Additionally, manually applying it with a paintbrush would be extremely time-consuming. Many individuals who attempt this themselves often end up using too much paint, resulting in material costs exceeding $0.30 per square foot.

Having it professionally installed can pose some problems as well. Most companies that apply spray-on insulation paint usually focus on coating the roof decking, often leaving the joists untouched. This means the exposed joists can still emit some heat into the attic.

RFID Radiant Barrier Foil, offered by Energy Shield USA, earns recognition from ASHRAE, IRC, IBC, IECC, and RIMA while boasting a remarkable thermal emissivity of only .05. In practical terms, this means it can reflect more than 95% of radiant heat. This high reflectivity is a key factor in its efficiency. Why is there such a substantial difference? It’s due to the fact that it’s genuine commercial-grade aluminum, free of any cutting agents. Foil, in its essence, always outperforms paint, as numerous studies have demonstrated.

RFID Radiant Barrier Foil unquestionably meets the stringent criteria to be labeled a true radiant barrier. Its exceptional thermal emissivity of 0.05 is a key characteristic defining a genuine radiant barrier. Unlike the paint alternatives, Radiant Barrier Foil provides comprehensive coverage, enveloping both roof decking and joists, ensuring every component of the attic space is shielded from radiant heat. This comprehensive insulation is a hallmark of a bona fide radiant barrier, solidifying Radiant Barrier Foil’s position as a highly effective solution for homeowners seeking to combat excessive heat gain in their homes.

In addition, ES® RFID Radiant Barrier Foil blocks potentially harmful radiofrequency (RF) radiation. Many modern electronic devices, including cell phones, Wi-Fi routers, and Bluetooth-enabled devices, emit RF radiation. While RF radiation is generally considered safe in small doses, high levels of prolonged exposure can potentially cause harm. Energy Shield USA RF/RFID shielding reflective insulation works by blocking RF radiation from entering a space.

Installing Radiant Barrier Foil is a straightforward DIY process. In fact, it’s difficult to install the foil wrong. Due to its non-toxic and non-carcinogenic nature, it doesn’t require the use of protective clothing or respirators during installation. You can easily install it using only a staple gun, scissors and ES® Metalized Tape.

Where does radiant foil offer the most benefit? Radiant foil barriers are most effective in spaces where there’s ample airspace between the foil and the surface to which it’s affixed. This airspace serves as a critical performance factor. Consequently, the optimal installation of a foil barrier is typically in the attic. Fortunately, the attic is also where the majority of unwanted thermal gains tend to occur in the average home. Applying it to the underside of roof sheathing will create a barrier that prevents the transfer of radiant heat into your living space.

While both RFID Radiant Barrier Foil and Spray-On Radiant Barrier are options, it’s clear that Radiant Barrier Foil stands out in terms of efficiency and effectiveness in reflecting radiant heat while providing RF protection. Its high thermal emissivity of .05 makes it a powerful insulating choice for your home. Because of its exceptional reflective properties, RFID Radiant Barrier Foil provides a superior level of insulation, contributing to a more comfortable indoor environment while lowering energy bills.

In conclusion, when it comes to Radiant Barrier Foil vs. Paint, the numbers speak for themselves. For optimal radiant heat insulation, ES® RFID Radiant Barrier Foil is the superior choice.

I hope you find this blog helpful! If you have any further questions or need additional information, feel free to contact us.